What Is an I-9 Audit?

11 May


The term “I-9 audit” strikes dread in the heart of many employers, but it doesn’t need to be that way.

The federal government requires that all U.S. employers complete a Form I-9—aka the Employment Eligibility Verification form—for every worker they hire. The I-9 verifies that the employee—whether citizen or noncitizen—is authorized to work here. An I-9 audit is a thorough review of an employer’s I-9 forms.

Here’s the twist: There are two types of I-9 audits:

  • Those conducted by the government
  • Those conducted by the employers themselves.

Do one right, and it will hold you in good stead should you be subject to the other!

Download Our Free Benefits Guide

Download our Benefits Brochure to see how we can provide Fortune 500-level benefits at a fraction of the cost.

Download Guide


Both types of I-9 audits ensure that:

  • There’s a Form I-9 on file for all active (and some former) employees
  • Each I-9 form is complete and accurate
  • The forms are based on authentic documentation

Beyond that common objective, I-9 audits differ in how they’re conducted—and what happens next. 

Anatomy of a Federal I-9 Audit

Form I-9 falls under the province of the U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services (USCIS). Most I-9 audits are conducted by U.S. Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE). Sometimes, I-9 audits are because of random sampling; others are triggered by employee tip-offs.

Either way, agents must give employers at least three business days’ notice before starting an inspection.

How likely is it that a federal I-9 audit will turn up some problems? Very! About 76% of paper I-9s have at least one error or omission, according to the USCIS Outreach Branch.

When minor errors (e.g., missing dates or signatures) are found, employers have 10 days under the good-faith provision to correct them. When more substantive violations are identified—say, ICE determines that an employees’ documents are invalid—things can escalate quickly.

The Cost of an I-9 Audit

The current I-9 paperwork penalty ranges from $234 to $2,322 depending on employer size, total violations and other factors. Given how common these errors are, things can get pricey in a hurry.

The penalties for knowingly hiring unauthorized workers are much stiffer, ranging from $590 to $4,722 for a first offense to as much as $23,607 for a third offense.

ICE conducted more than 6,450 I-9 audits in 2019, resulting in 2,675 arrests and more than $14 million in fines. While the pandemic limited subsequent audits, they are expected to ramp up in the coming months.   

Schedule a Call

Learn more about VensureHR and how we can make an impact on your business.

Contact VensureHR

Conducting an I-9 Audit

The best way to skate through an I-9 audit unscathed is simple: Be rigorous about Form 1-9 completion and documentation and conduct regular internal I-9 audits.

Many employers use third-party HR specialists to ensure an objective internal I-9 audit. However, if you do use in-house staff, make sure they follow a formal, meticulous process—and that those performing your audit are not those who completed the forms originally.   

The term “federal I-9 audit” isn’t one that most employers want to hear, but if you practice your due diligence, there’s really nothing to fear. 

Subscribe to
The Vensure Voice

Subscribe to
The Vensure Voice


You're all set.

Thanks for subscribing. Be on the look out for The Vensure Voice, our newsletter full of helpful resources, up-to-date info and more!