Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Navigating Through Payroll Deductions (1)

Managing payroll requires strict attention to which deductions are legally allowed. Seemingly small mistakes in this regard can lead to major legal problems. It’s critical to ensure you’re in compliance with rightful allowable deductions at all times. This overview, while not comprehensive, is a brief look at the basics of mandatory, legal and unlawful deductions. Each individual case must considered in detail, as various policies apply in different situations and in each state.

Mandatory Deductions

By law, these deductions are required to be withheld from an employee’s gross earnings:

  • FICA Tax – FICA deductions fund both Social Security and Medicare. Although each tax is calculated at different rates, the aggregate monies are collected together via the FICA deduction.
  • Federal Income Tax.
  • State Income Tax – If applicable.
  • Local Tax – If applicable, as directed by county, city or other regional mandates.
  • Wage Garnishments – Imposed by federal or state law.

Voluntary Deductions

These are deductions that may legally be taken, but are not required to be deducted from the employee’s gross pay. Voluntary deductions may be initiated by the written request of the employee. With that said, an employee’s written permission doesn’t always legally grant the deduction of monies from a paycheck, such as deducting the balance of monies owed to the employer when receiving a final check due to termination.

Lawful deductions that an employer may withhold include:

  • Voluntary contributions to health plans, pension plans, IRA accounts and union dues.
  • For exempt employees, sick or personal days, FMLA leave and disciplinary actions.

It is important to note that permissions regarding what is or is not allowed can depend on whether the employee is exempt or non-exempt. An employer may dock the wages of a non-exempt employee in order to reimburse for damaged property or similar expenses for which the employee is directly responsible, but these deductions may not take the employee’s total wages below minimum wage. This is true even if the employer suffers losses due to the employee’s theft of company money or property.

Further, if such deductions are incurred during a week which includes overtime earnings, specific rules apply that require the overtime wage to remain at the original (i.e., not docked) rate.

Unlawful Deductions

  • Gratuities.
  • Reducing pay for exempt employees providing little or poor work (but, zero work during the week can trigger withholding).
  • Uniforms – The Fair Standards Labor Act does not require that employees purchase uniforms; however, this business expense may be passed to employees in some states (though, you are still required to ensure the total earnings minus the deduction is not putting the employee below minimum wage), yet is unlawful in other states, such as California.
  • Other items that benefit the employer; e.g., business cards, company photographs, company mandated medical examinations.
  • Work-related expenses.

Not only are federal court decisions interpreted in various ways by the state courts, many states have specific statutes detailing what may and may not be deducted from paychecks (even with the employee’s written “consent”). Wandering into murky territory regarding deductions can spell trouble for a company and those involved in authorizing the questionable deductions. Always make sure you are familiar with the specific requirements of your state before you just assume a deduction is lawful.

If you’re ever in doubt about how to proceed, contact us, and avoid making a tricky situation worse!


Vensure Employer Services

Hiring During the Government Shutdown

Dear Valued Clients,

Wondering how the government shutdown affects hiring? Well, here’s what you need to know about processing forms during the shutdown.

What do employers do with the Form I-9?
Continue to complete the I-9 process in a timely manner.

What is the E-Verify process?
Document your attempt to process the E-Verify within the required time frame. Create a tracking spreadsheet that flags any new hire without an E-Verify confirmation. Be sure to process the E Verify once the system is functioning. Select “other” for the reason code for processing after the 3-day window. You will be provided a notes section to notate the “Government Shutdown” as the reason.

What are the deadlines for completing Form I-9 and E-Verify?

  • Form I-9 – Complete once the employee has accepted an employment offer. The latest this can be submitted is the third business day after the employee starts paid work.
  • E-Verify – Complete once the employee has accepted an offer of employment and has completed the Form I-9. The lastest a case can be created is the third business day after the employee started working for pay and the I-9 is complete.

What about employers who are subject to FAR(Federal Acquisition Requirements)?
Contact a Federal Contract Liaison for guidance on new hires.

What’s happening with the Social Security office during the shutdown?
The Social Security office is open, but will not issue new or replacement cards; however, you can verify or change citizenship. For more details, please visit

What if the new hire has trouble completing the I-9?
For issues with new hires not being able to produce required documentation, there may be situtations where the deadline for document presentation can be extended. Also, most state offices, such as the DMV, are open.

If you have further questions about how to handle new hire paperwork during the government shutdown, please contact your Client Relations Manager.

Vensure Employer Services


Get 2 Months Free Admin

Schedule a Business Diagnostic and we'll lock in 2 months free admin when you sign with us.

Get 2 Months Free Admin

Schedule a Business Diagnostic and we'll lock in 2 months free admin when you sign with us.

Schedule Your Live Demo

In just 30 minutes you can see what streamlined HR management looks like.


  • MM slash DD slash YYYY
    We will contact you to confirm a time.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.